Eagle Claw vs. Water Gremlin: Which Split Shot Should You Grab?

Photo Credit: Jack Wrobel

When it comes to getting your bait or fly right where the fish are, the right split shot makes all the difference. At The Knotty Angler, we stock two trusted favorites: Eagle Claw Removable Split Shot and Water Gremlin Removable Split Shot — both ready to help you fine-tune your rig for trout, panfish, or whatever’s biting.

Eagle Claw Split Shot is the classic, budget-friendly option for everyday fishing. It’s easy to clamp on your line, holds well, and removes when you’re done. Quality is good but basic — some anglers note occasional inconsistency in how tight the shot clamps, especially on thicker or very fine lines.The lead is soft enough to crimp easily but can get misshapen if opened and closed repeatedly. Overall, this removable split shot is great for everyday use when you want affordable, no-fuss sinkers and don’t mind replacing them when they deform. Right now, Eagle Claw shot is 20% OFF, so it’s the perfect time to stock up.

Water Gremlin Split Shot is our pick when you want extra precision. Known for its consistent roundness, uniform size, and dependable clamp strength, this split shot protects your line while staying securely in place. The smooth “ears” design makes it easy to open and adjust without causing line damage — a big plus over cheaper alternatives. If you’re fine-tuning delicate nymph rigs or fishing ultra-light, Water Gremlin’s quality and consistency are tough to beat.

👉 Both Eagle Claw and Water Gremlin split shot are available exclusively in-store right now — so swing by, ask us which one fits your setup best, and we’ll get you rigged and ready.

Keep 'em lines tight, and see you at the shop!